Hi y’all,
Jane wrote:
But she stated if one wants the best txs available, they will choose the machine that doctors on dialysis choose, PHD.
In all fairness, Nephnurse (who never identified her(?)self) wrote that message before the Allient Sorbent system was approved by the FDA.
From my perspective as Executive Director of the Medical Education Institute (which created this site)–and I’ve shared this with ALL of the folks who make these machines–I’m glad they’re all on the market, because I want patients to have the widest possible choice of modalities and equipment. And anything I write below is solely based on my current knowledge of each system–which is not perfect. (So, folks, if I get a detail wrong, please feel free to correct me).
People’s situations vary quite a bit. If you rent a large apartment and have plenty of storage space–but can’t change the plumbing or wiring, then PD with or w/o a cycler or the NxStage machine might be the best fit for your life. The same is true if you plan to travel & want to be able to put your machine in the car & ship your supplies. Or, if you want a system that will only take a couple of weeks to learn.
If you live in your own home & can change plumbing & wiring, then you might be very happy with the BBraun, Fresenius 2008 K series, or the Aksys PHD, all of which can offer you excellent treatment. The Aksys system uses fewer supplies, because it disinfects with heat & reuses the dialyzer & tubing for a month–and has many other benefits that folks who know the system in more detail have outlined in other posts.
The Allient Sorbent system is unique & somewhere in between, in that it doesn’t need plumbing changes–it uses tap water & treats it itself. I don’t know if it needs wiring changes, but I don’t think so. It’s not as transportable as the Nxstage, but like the BBraun & Fresenius machines, it’s very flexible in terms of treatment length–it can do short daily, conventional 3-5 hour treatments, or long nocturnal.
To paraphrase Pierre has said, and I agree with him, the technology is a means to an end. The point is to get longer and/or more frequent dialysis, and to be able to get the treatment YOU want that will best fit your life. Exactly which machine will work best for your needs will depend on your individual situation. Also, some people’s choices are constrained by what their home clinic will offer–I’d hate to have people not choose a home treatment because they can’t get a particular machine that they have their hearts set on.