“Moosemum” posted the following statement under the heading ‘Culture Gap between Corporations and Patients’ at Gary Petersons website and blog page “Fix Dialysis” [http://www.fixdialysis.com] …
“All I know is that I’ve done extensive searches for in-clinic nocturnal dialysis, and I have found nothing within 50 miles of me. I’ve also learned from my local clinic that they have only one patient in the entire county doing NxStage…and I am just outside of Chicago, not exactly the hinterland.”
‘Dori Schatell, from Home Dialysis Central [http://www.homedialysis.org ]
"It IS hard to find in-center nocturnal programs. Your best bet is to contact the LDOs and ask where their nearest programs to you are [NB: this statement applies to US readers only] … but … think about the hours, though, and do think about home."
I agree wholeheartedly with Dori that Moosemum … and all the others out there wanting the very best from their dialysis … should embrace the idea that “home is best.”
Simply put – it is!
Why?
- Dialysis at home puts you in total control of your own destiny. You no longer need to depend on others – others who, despite all their best intentions, have commitments of their own beyond and sometimes above their commitment to you, their dialysis patient … and, even more, you are not their only dialysis patient.
At home, you are master of your own care. Our experience tells us that no-one takes more care, is more meticulous with their fistula, more attuned to their own dialysis, the nuances of how they feel, than a patient him/herself. No-one!
At home, you set your own timetable. You dialyse to suit yourself –and no-one else. Any form of facility care – except perhaps the Auckland model from New Zealand – imposes a schedule other than your own. This includes facility-based (in-centre) nocturnal dialysis.
- Facility-based nocturnal dialysis delivers extended hour treatment – and make no mistake, this is a decided benefit. For that, it gets much credit. But, facility-based nocturnal does not deliver on frequency. I am not aware (and maybe I can be corrected here if I am wrong) of any facility-based nocturnal program, anywhere, that offers more than 3 nights per week.
Three nights of dialysis per week implies – no, it demands – a long break! A long break is inevitably stressful to the heart, the circulation, the blood pressure and the body as a whole. I have expanded on this point many times in answers to previous posts at this site.
It has also often been shown by others that, in standard dialysis programs, many more deaths occur on Sunday nights (the long-break ‘end’ night of the Monday/Wednesday/Friday 3 x week shift) and on Monday nights (the long-break ‘end’ night of the Tuesday/Thursday/Saturday 3 x week shift).
We know that the long break is the single most mortal ‘event’ in the weekly calendar of any dialysis patient and yet facility-based nocturnal dialysis has, sadly, missed the opportunity of correcting this and has imposed the same frequency rosters on its patient population as conventional 3 x week dialysis has done for all these years. What a missed opportunity - but opportunities once missed tend to remain un-taken.
- Only at home can a dialysis frequency of at least 7 treatments each two weeks … a ‘rolling’ roster … be established. More than that, the home dialysis schedule can even more frequent – to the limits of tolerance and acceptability of the individual patient.
While in my own program we encourage a 5 night per week program for our patients, some prefer to do less while others prefer to do more. Treatments for our home nocturnal patients vary from every other night through to 6 nights in every week – as desired by the patients.
However, one thing is clear … all our patients do at least alternate night treatments and all have abolished the long-break. This is also true of the vast majority of Australian home dialysis patients and all of the patients in my own program.
So … home nocturnal dialysis offers the very best of the possible options in dialysis … longer treatment length and higher treatment frequency.
I have discussed these issues in far greater depth at my website http://www.nocturnaldialysis.org in my discussion re the various available dialysis modalities in the Dialysis Choices section, in the Dialysis Issues subsection on Blood Pressure and Ultrafiltration and elsewhere in the Comprehensive Nocturnal Dialysis section where I discuss sessional frequency and treatment length.
Dori is right … … think about the hours, though, and do think about home.