The reason so-called “short daily” hemodialysis works better than 3 times per week hemo is because during a dialysis treatment, except for fluid removal, most of the work is done in the first 2 hours of treatment. That’s the rationale behind short daily hemodialysis.
However, there is just no way that 2 hours 6 days per week is as good as 6-8 hours 6 nights per week. It’s good, but it’s not as good as nocturnal. For example, short daily for most people is a 2 hour treatment. That’s what it was for me. Total blood volume for a 2 hour treatment running the blood pump at 400 was in the neighbourhood of 44. On 6 hours of nocturnal running at 300, total blood volume through the machine is more like 105. So, that’s one heck of a big difference. It’s such a big difference that on nocturnal hemo, not only do you not have to diet for phosphorus, they have to add some to your dialysate. You can take your dialysis diet package and throw it out the window. Moreover, there is NO fluid restriction. The only fluid restriction is what your body can handle without you becoming short of breath before the next treatment. There IS a fluid restriction with short daily, because you can only remove so much fluid in a 2 hour treatment, and even in a 3 hour treatment. Now, it’s important to note that fluid is never totally free, because there’s always a chance you might have to miss a treatment due to a machine breakdown - so you have to keep it within reasonable limits, no matter what kind of dialysis you do.
The other issue is that with nocturnal, fluid removal is spread over 6 to 8 hours. That results in a fairly low ultrafiltration rate. By contrast, for the same weight gain, short daily has a pretty high UF rate. The lower UF rate is much, much less stressful on the body, and the heart in particular. Cramps in the legs and queasyness in the stomach become a thing of the past. There is virtually zero recovery time needed after nocturnal hemo, unless you haven’t been able to get sleep that night. Short daily hemo is the same as 3/week hemo, except more frequent. Same dialysate flow, same blood flow. During nocturnal, blood flow runs at 300, and dialysate flow runs at 300. It almost feels like nothing is happening at all. And since the flows are so low, the arterial and venous pressures are significantly lower too. This means you can easily go through a whole night without even one alarm going off.
Now, of course, like some are doing, it’s possible to do longer short daily treatments, but, you have to know what you’re getting into. A 3 or 4 hour treatment 3 times a week is one thing, but, imagine doing that every day, 6 days per week (and having it be entirely your responsibility too). That’s half the day gone each day, and it’s a pretty relentless schedule. No matter what type of machine is used, there’s going to be setup and cleanup time in addition to that 3 or 4 hour treatment. With nocturnal, it might take a couple of weeks to get used to it, but you will sleep through most of it. I don’t know about anyone else, but when I was doing my dialysis in-centre, I used to consider any time I dozed off during the treatment as a Godsend. There’s nothing like waking up when it’s over.
There isn’t much controlled clinical trial evidence about either form of daily hemodialysis (due to the almost impossibility of controlled clinical trials in that setting), but boy, there’s a lot of good observational evidence. For me, there’s no contest. Daily nocturnal hemodialysis is simply the best treatment that nephrology has to offer. It’s so good that you may begin to wonder if it’s worth going through the trouble and potential problems of a kidney transplant. It is worth getting a kidney, of course, but you might just stop to wonder if it is.
I’m not saying short daily is not good - just to be clear, and I’m not putting down anyone’s choice. It would be my second choice if I couldn’t do nocturnal for whatever reason. But it’s not quite in the same league as daily nocturnal. When deciding, just keep in mind that doing a short daily treatment of just 2 hours will easily seem like it takes as long overall as an entire 3-1/2 to 4 hour in-centre treatment. I think most people don’t realize this until they actually do it. But, unlike the 3/week in-centre tmt, you are doing it virtually every day, and you are doing it yourself. It’s the same with nocturnal, but the idea is that it’s done during sleep time and it doesn’t impact on your daytime as much.
No matter what you do or choose, there are always downsides to anything. With nocturnal, one downside is that many people might not be as alert when setting up say at 10PM as they would at 10AM - but that’s nothing a good stiff cup of coffee can’t cure if necessary. Don’t worry about the caffeine keeping you awake later, because dialysis actually removes caffeine from your blood. And then there’s the issue of more limited sleeping positions. You won’t be sleeping on your stomach while doing nocturnal, but, you can easily curl up and sleep on either side, not just on your back. Also, at present, the machines suitable for nocturnal hemo won’t travel with you. But, should you want to travel, you can always revert to 3/week in-centre hemo during a trip, as long as you plan ahead. Also, don’t forget that the machine used for nocturnal can just as easily do short daily, and you can switch pretty much at will at times when it might be more convenient to do so.
Pierre